For Ohio drivers and homeowners

Compare car and home insurance prices from multiple carriers, right here.

Pick what you want to insure and answer a few questions. Our quote tool checks multiple carriers and shows you their prices right here. Want a second opinion? A Kaufman agent is one text away.

  • Prices from multiple carriersNot just one company.
  • Not a lead siteWe don’t sell your information or pass it to other agencies.
  • A real reviewAn agent calls to check your quote for accuracy. No hard sell.
  • Ohio-based agencyLicensed agents by phone, email and online.

Kaufman Insurance Group is an independent agency. We shop coverage with a range of insurance companies for people and businesses in Ohio and across the lower 48. Which companies fit depends on what you need and where you live.

  • GEICO
  • Progressive
  • National General, an Allstate company
  • Grange Insurance
  • Liberty Mutual Insurance
  • Travelers
  • Nationwide
  • Foremost, part of Farmers Insurance
  • Chubb
  • The Hartford
  • Lemonade
  • Hagerty
  • Clearcover
  • CNA
  • Hiscox
  • State Auto
  • Steadily
  • Obie
  • Open Road
  • Neptune Flood

Carrier names and logos identify insurance companies Kaufman Insurance Group may access as an independent agency. They do not imply endorsement by those companies. Availability and eligibility can vary by coverage, location, and insurer. This strip highlights a sample of companies we may be able to quote.

One Form real quotes customized for you right now!

  • Compare real prices from multiple companies on one screen as soon as you submit.
  • Skip hours calling around, and getting bombarded with phone calls from pushy salespeople.
  • Compare right away and see what you could be saving right now!
Your quote results Example
  • Progressive
  • National General, an Allstate company
  • Grange Insurance
  • GEICO
  • Foremost, part of Farmers Insurance
Example of what you’ll see. Your real prices show up on one screen after you submit.
See my prices

Our online quote tool covers Ohio only, and it doesn’t include every carrier we work with. For more options, call or text us at 330-486-8404. Outside Ohio? We can still help. Use our quote form or give us a call.

The carrier sets your final price after its review, and coverage starts once it approves your policy and you make your first payment.

Trouble seeing the quote tool? Open it in a new tab or call or text 330-486-8404.

Not one of those quote sites

You may have filled out a form before and gotten calls from more than one agent. This isn’t that. Your information comes only to Kaufman Insurance Group. We don’t sell it or pass it to other agencies. The carriers we quote use your answers to price your policy. One of our agents will call to go over your quote for accuracy. No hard sell, no pressure. See our Privacy Policy.

How it works

Pick what you want to insure.

Your car or your home, or bundle them.

Answer a few questions.

About your drivers and cars, or about your home.

See your prices.

Prices from multiple carriers show up on one screen.

Pick one, or ask us.

Choose a price you like. An agent will call to go over it for accuracy and help you finish.

Start my quote

Who you’re working with

You may not know us yet, so here’s who we are. Kaufman Insurance Group is an independent insurance agency based in Ohio. We work with you by phone, email and online.

John Kaufman, founder of Kaufman Insurance Group

Meet John

Licensed insurance agent

Before John started Kaufman Insurance Group, he spent about 8 years at National General, an Allstate company. He was one of their top agents and helped more than 10,000 customers. Along the way he learned what makes one company a better fit than another for your car or home, and the questions that catch a gap in your coverage before it costs you. Now our team compares multiple companies for you, and if what you have is already a good deal, we’ll tell you. Check your prices above, or call or text us at 330-486-8404.

  • How we workBy phone, email and online, for drivers and homeowners across Ohio.
  • Call or text330-486-8404 (John is ext. 101)
  • Licensed agentsA licensed agent on our team reviews your quote with you. Check your prices.
  • Meet the teamSee our agents on the About page.

Why use an independent agent?

A captive agent can only sell one company’s policies. We work with multiple carriers, like the ones you see above, and many more, so we can compare their prices for you. If your price goes up at renewal, we can check the other carriers again instead of starting over.

Start my quote

Save time. Get choices. Make one call.

We can shop 13 auto companies and 8 home companies for you. Getting those same quotes yourself, one call at a time, could take up to about 10.5 hours. With us, it’s one call.

One call with us

About 15 to 30 minutes

We usually have your car and home prices the same day, from all the companies we can shop. No sales pitch.

Calling each company yourself

Car: 13 companies x 15 to 30 minutes eachAbout 3.25 to 6.5 hours
Home: 8 companies x 15 to 30 minutes eachAbout 2 to 4 hours
Car and home togetherUp to about 10.5 hours

Many of the people we talk to have already spent 4 to 7 hours or more shopping by the time they call us.

Kaufman Insurance Group

How many companies you getOne agency. We can shop 13 auto companies and 8 home companies for you.
Where your information goesOnly to Kaufman Insurance Group. We don’t sell it.
How much of your time it takesIn Ohio, our online quote form takes just a couple of minutes. Submit it and you see prices from multiple carriers on one screen right away, so you can compare them right then and there. Rather talk? One call gets you all the companies we can shop, and we usually have your car and home prices the same day, in about 15 to 30 minutes for both.
How it feelsOne agent compares your options, calls to go over them, and lets you decide. No sales pitch.

We save you time and get you choices. That’s a big value with us.

Start my quote

Lead sites

How many companies you getOnly the agents who buy your information. You don’t get to pick them.
Where your information goesYour information can be sold to 4 to 20 agents the moment you submit, and each may call you 3 to 20 times. Every time it’s resold, the calls add up.
How much of your time it takesOne form, then an avalanche of calls, texts and emails. Each agent who calls can take 15 to 30 minutes just to quote your car.
How it feelsA lot of pushy salespeople calling and hard selling, because they all paid for that lead. National call centers push their agents to hit strict sales targets and sell you extras you don’t need. Local agents are desperate for a sale. Inexperienced agents may not be thorough, which can leave you exposed.

Single carriers and captive agents

How many companies you getThey work for one company, so you get one option. It may not be the best one for you.
Where your information goesTo that one company. To compare, you give it again at the next agency, and the next.
How much of your time it takesEach call takes about 15 to 30 minutes for a car quote and another 15 to 30 for home. Captive agents often take days to get back to you with prices. Multiply that by every company you call.
How it feelsEach call ends with a hard sell, especially at the carriers’ own call centers. Shopping around means enduring sales pitch after sales pitch.

Times and numbers are from our agents’ experience and vary. Company counts are for Ohio. Our online quote tool covers Ohio only, and it doesn’t include every company we work with. To shop more companies, call or text us at 330-486-8404.

Your prices, from multiple carriers, on one screen

  • Answer a few questions, and the tool checks multiple carriers we work with.
  • Each carrier’s price shows up in one list, by the month and the way the carrier quotes it.
  • Like one? Tap “I’m interested!” and we’re notified. A licensed agent on our team calls to fine-tune your coverage and deductible and look for discounts. No hard sell.

Start my quote

What to have ready

Having these handy makes your prices more accurate.

  • Each driver’s date of birth
  • Each car’s year, make and model, or its VIN
  • Your current policy, if you have one (the page that shows your coverage)
  • A few facts about your home, like the year it was built

Driver’s license numbers are optional. Adding them helps the carriers give you a more accurate price.

Want a second set of eyes?

Online prices are a great place to start. Our agents look at more than the price. They check your limits and your deductible. They also look for discounts you might be missing. Then we tell you which one we’d pick and why.

We’ll try to save you money. We often do, but not always. Either way, you’ll know what you’re buying.

Start my quote Text or call 330-486-8404

Questions people ask

Is this really free?

Yes. Checking prices costs nothing, and you don’t have to buy.

Will someone call me?

Yes. After you see your prices, one of our agents will call to go over your quote for accuracy, so your coverage and details are right. No hard sell, no pressure. If a text or another time works better, just tell us.

Are these prices final?

They’re prices from the carriers, based on what you enter. The carrier sets your final price after it reviews things like your driving and claims records. One of our agents will go over it with you so there are no surprises.

Will checking prices hurt my credit?

No. Checking prices uses a soft credit check, which doesn’t affect your credit score.

Who is Kaufman Insurance Group?

We’re an independent insurance agency based in Ohio, started by John. We work with you by phone, email and online, and with multiple carriers, so we can compare prices for car, home and more. You can reach us at 330-486-8404.

Will I get calls from a bunch of agents?

No. This isn’t a lead site. Some quote sites pass your form to many agents, which is why the calls pile up. Your information comes only to Kaufman Insurance Group. We don’t sell it or pass it to other agencies. The carriers we quote use your answers to price your policy. One of our agents will call to go over your quote for accuracy. No hard sell, no pressure.

Why does the quote tool mention Vertafore?

Our quote tool runs on software from Vertafore, a company that builds rating tools for insurance agents. Your answers come to Kaufman Insurance Group.

What happens after I see my prices?

Pick the one you like. One of our agents will call to go over your quote for accuracy and help you finish. No hard sell, no pressure.

Start my quote

Need something else?

Our online quote tool covers Ohio cars, homes, renters and condos, and it doesn’t include every carrier we work with. We can still help with anything else, including cars or homes outside Ohio. For more options, use our quote form below and an agent will do the shopping for you. You can also call or text us at 330-486-8404.

Ready to see your prices?

Scroll to Top