Someone rear-ends you at a light. It’s clearly their fault. Now you’re standing in the parking lot with a crunched bumper and one question: do I call my insurance company or theirs?
Ohio car and home insurance
Check your car or home insurance price
Pick what you want to insure. Our quote tool checks multiple carriers and shows you their prices on one screen.
Your information comes only to Kaufman Insurance Group. We don't sell it or pass it to other agencies. One of our agents will call to go over your quote for accuracy. No hard sell, no pressure.
Free to check. You don't have to buy anything.
This tool quotes Ohio only and doesn't include every carrier we work with.
Outside Ohio, or want more options? Call or text 330-486-8404 or use our other quote form.
When you’ve been in a not at fault accident, the short answer is that you can usually file with either one. Each road has a trade-off. Their company won’t charge you a deductible, but it may take longer. Your company can probably move faster, but you’ll likely pay your deductible up front and wait to get it back. Here’s how each one works, and what I tell my own clients to do first.
What a not at fault accident actually means
At fault means the driver who caused the accident. Ohio is not a no-fault state, so in most cases the at-fault driver’s liability insurance is the coverage that’s supposed to pay for the damage they caused. In other words, their policy pays for your car.
A third-party claim is a claim you file with the other driver’s insurance company. You aren’t their customer, so you’re the “third party.”
A first-party claim is a claim you file with your own insurance company, usually under your collision coverage. Collision is the part of your policy that pays to fix your own car after you hit something or something hits you. Not everyone carries it. If your car is paid off and you dropped collision to save money, this option may not be on the table.
Your deductible is the amount you pay out of your own pocket on a claim before your policy pays the rest.
Subrogation is a big word for a simple idea. After your company pays to fix your car, it goes after the at-fault driver’s company to get its money back. In other words, your insurer steps into your shoes and collects for you. If you want the deeper version, I wrote a full guide on how subrogation works when another party is at fault.
Option 1: File with the other driver’s insurance
This is the “make the person who caused it pay” route.
The good part: you don’t pay a deductible. If their company accepts the claim, it pays for the repairs on your car.
The catch: they don’t work for you. Their adjuster, the person who decides what the company will pay, is there to look out for their own customer and their own company. Before they pay anything, they usually want to confirm their driver was really at fault. That can mean waiting on their driver to report the accident, waiting on a police report, or waiting while they review the facts. If the other driver tells a different story, things can stall.
This route tends to work best when fault is crystal clear, the other driver admitted it, and you’re not in a big hurry.
Option 2: File with your own insurance
This is the “get my car fixed now and let the insurance companies sort it out” route.
The good part: your company works for you. You’re the customer, and you don’t need to wait for the other driver’s company to agree on fault before your own company starts moving on the repair.
The catch: you’ll probably have to pay your deductible up front. Your company then uses subrogation to collect from the at-fault driver’s company. In Ohio, insurance rules say your company has to include your deductible when it asks the other company to pay it back. If it only gets part of the money back, it has to give you a fair share of what it recovers, in proportion to your deductible. So you will probably get your deductible back, but it isn’t guaranteed, and it can take a while.
This route tends to work best when you need your car back quickly, fault is being argued, or the other driver’s company is slow to call you back.
Not at fault accident: their insurance or yours
| Their insurance | Your insurance | |
|---|---|---|
| Who pays for repairs | The at-fault driver’s company | Your company, then it collects from theirs |
| Your deductible | None | Usually paid up front, probably refunded later |
| Speed | Can be slower while they decide fault | Often faster since you’re their customer |
| Who’s on your side | Nobody, really | Your own company |
| Needs collision coverage | No | Yes |
What if their insurance isn’t enough, or they don’t have any?
This is where people get burned. Ohio’s minimum liability coverage is $25,000 for damage to other people’s property in one accident. In other words, if the other driver only carries the state minimum, their policy pays up to $25,000 for all the property they damaged in that wreck. That money can go fast with a newer car, more than one car involved, or a total loss.
And some drivers don’t have insurance at all. That’s what uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage is for. That’s coverage on your own policy that steps in when the driver who hit you has no insurance or not enough. Here’s my take on whether Ohio uninsured motorist coverage is worth it.
Not sure if your policy has collision or uninsured motorist coverage? Most people aren’t until they need it. We’ll look at what you have now and show you what it would take to close the gaps. Start a quote here.
What about injuries?
Car damage and injuries don’t always follow the same path. Twelve states and Puerto Rico have no-fault laws, which means your own policy pays for injuries to you and your passengers no matter who caused the accident. Minnesota and Michigan are two of them. Ohio isn’t one.
No-fault rules are mainly about injuries, and the rules for car damage can work differently from state to state. So if you get hurt in a wreck out of state, the rules for your medical bills may be different from the rules for your car. That’s a good reason to call your agent before you call anyone else.
What I tell my clients to do first
Whichever way you go, call your own agent or your own company early. Most auto policies say your company must be told promptly about an accident, even when it wasn’t your fault. If the other driver changes their story next week, or their insurance turns out to be canceled, you’ll be glad your own company already knows.
Then:
- Get the other driver’s name, insurance company, policy number, and plate number at the scene.
- Take photos of both cars, the scene, and the road.
- Ask the officer how to get the accident report.
- Write down every claim number, adjuster name, and date you talk to someone.
- Don’t feel rushed into agreeing to a repair estimate or a settlement you don’t understand. Ask the adjuster to explain the decision in writing.
Here’s my honest advice. If the other company accepts fault quickly and treats you right, let them pay. If they drag their feet or start arguing about fault, and you carry collision, it’s often worth letting your own company fix your car and chase the money. That’s part of what you pay your insurance for.
Common questions
Will a not-at-fault claim raise my rates?
It depends on the company and the state, so nobody can promise you either way. Ask your company how it handles a not-at-fault claim at renewal before you decide. If you want to know how an at-fault accident usually plays out, here’s how much a single at-fault accident can raise your rates.
Do I get a rental car?
Maybe. Ask the at-fault driver’s company if it will cover a rental while your car is in the shop. If you go through your own company, rental help usually depends on whether you carry rental reimbursement on your policy. Here’s how rental car reimbursement coverage works.
My car is fixed, but it’s worth less now. Can I claim that?
That’s called diminished value, and whether you can collect it depends on the state, the policy, and who you file with. Here’s more on diminished value and when you can claim it.
What if their company says the car is totaled?
Then the question becomes what your car was worth right before the accident, not what you paid for it. Here’s how insurance companies figure total loss value.
Make sure your own policy has your back next time
Here’s the part most people only think about after a wreck. When the other driver is at fault, the coverage that saves you is often on your own policy: collision, uninsured and underinsured motorist, and rental. If you aren’t sure what your policy has, that’s exactly what we’re here for.
Kaufman Insurance Group is licensed in all 48 lower states, and we’ll compare options from multiple carriers so your coverage fits how you really drive. Get a quote or learn more about our auto insurance.
Outside Ohio, or need RV, boat or business insurance?
We can help with that too. Tell us what you need here and one of our agents will get back to you. Rather talk? Call or text 330-486-8404.



